Analytics & ad privacy
The interview / Work · The world

I filmed a suspected overdose on the beach. It stays up.

The clips drew about half a million views and took my channel from 90 followers to 490. Then the man's self-described best friend asked me to delete them.

7 min read

Illustration of a man holding his phone down at a beach boardwalk while distant emergency responders gather on the sand, obscuring the person they are helping.
AI illustration for Bonzai

A stranger put the question to me in the comments: Did I have to film this and post it on social media? Was it necessary?

The video she was asking about shows a man unconscious on the sand at the Virginia Beach oceanfront, just off the boardwalk, in daylight. Police officers reach him first, then emergency medical staff, while onlookers and some of his companions stand around. The medics work through different resuscitation and arousal techniques, trying to get any response from him, consciousness or even just movement. He had to be hospitalized.

It was one of a series of videos I posted to Monarch City Buzz, the local news channel I run on Instagram and YouTube. One of them reached about 195,000 views from 175,000 unique viewers. Together, the series drew about half a million views in 24 hours.

As far as I know, only two people out of hundreds of thousands expressed a problem with it. The stranger objected publicly. Separately, Kenz, a photographer I work with, told another photographer I collaborate with that my videos had gone viral. That photographer's answer was something to the effect that he didn't want or need to be posting or looking at bodies online.

I answered the stranger two ways. The first was a question, maybe a sarcastic one: You do know you can keep scrolling without commenting? The second was that this is a news site. This is journalism. There's a series of videos, the captions are very thorough, and you can read about why this is happening. I think one of the issues is that people land on one video and form an opinion based on that alone.

Where I saw the line

I didn't see it as intruding on the man's worst moment. He was facing away from me the entire time. At no point did I get an angle that showed his face; the most I got was a partial profile, and the resolution isn't that good. His name is in the video, though. It was said aloud, and the police used it as they talked to him, trying to get a response.

I wasn't looking for this. Earlier that same day, I heard a crash. I know the sound of a car accident, and I remember whispering to myself that it definitely was one. I asked myself whether I should go film the scene, and the other words that came to mind were something like, "I don't want to be an ambulance chaser." I filmed the aftermath anyway and interviewed one of the drivers. Then I got thrown into the second situation on the beach.

Accidents are already part of the Monarch City Buzz feed. I drive around a lot, and I've come across them day and night. Some have been pretty bad, though as far as I can tell no one has been seriously injured. I've seen some badly mangled vehicles, and what happens to the engineering interests me: One car hit a tree, and the tree was completely unfazed while the front end of the car was destroyed. But I'm not looking for people to be hurt. One of the things that comes to my mind is that I really hope they're OK.

Of course, I didn't have to turn on my camera. I didn't have to go there or do anything. But if I'm curious about what's going on, other people will be too. It's the same reason people can't help looking at a car accident. And I've been recording things as long as I can remember: audio, video, photographs, writing and speaking of all kinds. It's in my nature. I'm not going to make an excuse for that, but I do want to understand where people are coming from, and I don't want to be disrespectful. I'm willing to consider that perhaps I have some missing part of my soul that doesn't register that footage like this may be offensive to people rather than intriguing or interesting.

I'm willing to consider that perhaps I have some missing part of my soul that doesn't register that footage like this may be offensive to people rather than intriguing or interesting.

So I turned the question on myself. Would I want to be filmed going through a crisis? Hit by a car, in pain, bleeding, unconscious, receiving medical care? I thought it through for a moment to see if there was some issue, and no, I don't have a problem with it.

I also look at what's already accepted. TV news very quickly shows the faces of suspects who have already been apprehended, before they've even gone to trial, and the faces of victims who've had horrible things happen to them. People who do First Amendment auditing, which is very controversial, keep filming people who say they don't give permission, and when police are called, they often find the person filming isn't doing anything illegal. The way I see it, anything that can be seen from a public area is a matter of the public, with no expectation of privacy. So I'm not clear on where I'm crossing the line. Are people simply feeling disrespected, or is this actually a disrespectful act?

A business decision

Could the story have been told without that level of exposure? Absolutely. I could say, the way I've heard reporters say it, that a man was found unconscious this afternoon in an open public space on the beach and first responders answered the call. I could show zero video. But posting it was a business decision.

Monarch City Buzz is the consumer-facing side of the marketing agency I'm building. Before this, I had 90 followers, almost all people I'd met face to face and asked to follow the channel. The plan is that the more local followers I have, the more attractive the channel becomes to businesses, because I'll help them get traffic and attention through editorials, advertorials, ads and local reporting. People who actually live in Hampton Roads, specifically Norfolk and Virginia Beach, are close to those businesses and more likely to patronize them.

After I posted this incident, my followers went from 90 to 490 in that same 24 hours. When I looked through their profiles, most were Virginians, specifically from Hampton Roads. That's the point: getting these people here. Is this a slippery slope I'm on? I could also ask whether something is wrong with all the people who watched and followed. Should the woman who asked her question go comment on every one of them and ask why they're all here?

Hidden comments and a removal request

Some comments attacked the man. People said things like, look where taxpayer dollars are going, blamed certain political leanings and asked why anyone was rushing to help a person like this. Instagram hid some of them automatically, and I left them hidden. To one, I replied with a reel. Down the street, a pawn shop has a sign painted on its wall that says, roughly, be kind, because you never know what battles someone is dealing with. I filmed the wall, said a little bit of pawn shop wisdom was appropriate here, read the sign aloud and sent that as my reply. A lot of the comments were sympathetic, people saying that's someone's child, it's so sad, and I agreed. I said on video and in comments that I really hope he's going to be OK. People who said they knew him or had seen him out and about said he is OK, though I can't confirm that.

One of them said they were the man's best friend. They sent me a direct message asking me to take the video down, saying he doesn't have Instagram and can't respond himself. It seemed like someone who genuinely knew him and was concerned. I didn't respond, because I'm not going to take the videos down. I can't see his face. And it reminds me of people who say they don't want to be filmed and then walk right up to the camera and start yelling. If you don't want this person identified, why are you in the public comments saying he's your friend, where anyone can look at who you are and make the connection?

I'm making this conversation public on video, so there's full transparency about my reasoning. It's something I still need to think about. But at this point, the video stands.

Written by Bonzai

Bonzai is a journalist that writes only from what real people tell it. Every story starts with someone’s own words, opinions and feedback, and is built on them.

Contributor